The Only Spot in Central Florida Serving This Wild Limited-Edition Ice Cream

John Graham • November 11, 2025

Think Pumpkin Spice, but Chili — Available for a Short Time at Horizon West Area Skyline Chili Location

Skyline Chili is a Cincinnati tradition that borders on obsession. You can buy it by the bowl, but loyal fans often order it over spaghetti mounded with shredded cheddar or ladled over a hot dog.


What makes Skyline Chili distinctive is the spices. Inspired by his Greek and Macedonian ancestry, founder Nicholas Lambrinides created a meat sauce spiked with cinnamon, allspice, cloves and more … we think. After more than 75 years, the exact recipe is still a secret.


For a limited time, Skyline Chili has teamed up with another Ohio tradition, Graeter’s Ice Cream, and added those sweet spices to a frozen mash-up. Don’t worry, there’s no chili powder, onion or ground beef in Graeter’s Skyline Spice French Pot Ice Cream.


To try this frozen treat in Horizon West, and around Central Florida, the only place is the Skyline Chili restaurant in Flamingo Crossings.

From Cincinnati to Central Florida: A Dream Come True

Franchise owner and Horizon West resident Daniel Hunsucker grew up in the Cincinnati area and, two years ago, fulfilled his dream to open a Skyline Chili in Central Florida. “In high school, I used to go five days a week. I eat a Cheese Coney (hot dog) every single day of my life.”


Daniel was understandably skeptical when he heard about Graeter’s Skyline Spice Ice Cream. Chili and ice cream don’t exactly sound like a natural pairing. “That’s what I first thought until I actually tried it and said, ‘Oh, they pulled this off!’ I would describe our chili as those warm, fall flavors. It’s still those warm, fall flavors, but ice cream.”

What Does Chili-Inspired Ice Cream Taste Like?

So, a quick review… What hits you with the first spoonful is the allspice. It’s a bit like pumpkin spice, but more of a spiced chai latte flavor.


If you’re unfamiliar with Skyline Chili, it's the cinnamon and cloves that give it a Christmassy, gingerbread vibe. If you do know Skyline, the influence jumps right out at you. There’s also a crunchy kick from mixed-in oyster crackers, the traditional accompaniment to Skyline Chili. They’re coated in just enough glaze to keep the crackers crisp while also adding a pop of savory and salt.


The Flamingo Crossings Skyline Chili location sells five-ounce tubs of Graeter’s Skyline Spice Ice Cream for $11.70 (after tax) from a freezer also stocked with other Graeter’s flavors as well. One of the classic flavors, Black Raspberry Chocolate Chip, is available too!


“Guests swear by putting our hot sauce on Graeter’s Skyline Spice ice cream,” says Daniel. “I have yet to try it, but I’ve had many people tell me it really works.”


Graeter’s Skyline Spice Ice Cream is a limited-time item, so while Daniel has the freezer stocked with enough to take him through Thanksgiving, he’s not sure if it will be available through Christmas. If you’re curious — or got a craving — grab some while you can!


📍Skyline Chili - 2231 Western Way B, Winter Garden, FL 34787


Stay updated on all of the community news in Horizon West by Signing up for Our eNewsletter >>

 


Share This Story...

November 12, 2025
Delivering Award-Winning Innovation and Compassionate Care Close to Home
By Ally Golden November 4, 2025
Helping Individuals and Families Thrive by Promoting Understanding and Acceptance
By John Graham October 28, 2025
Here’s Where Visiting Relatives (or Future Locals) Can Stay Without Taking Over Your House
By Stephanie Alvarado Guzzardi October 21, 2025
How Horizon West Families are Raising Children with Both Roots and Wings
By Stephanie Alvarado Guzzardi October 20, 2025
Cómo las familias de Horizon West están criando hijos con raíces y alas
By Ally Golden October 17, 2025
Find Fall Flavors and Experiences in Our Area
By Leah Emmanouilidis October 16, 2025
Sponsors and Players Contribute to Rotary Club Community-based Initiatives
By Jen Dixon October 8, 2025
A culinary celebration blending bold flavors and community impact
By John Graham October 1, 2025
Dirty Soda, Florida Seafood, Sushi, Coffee and More — Here’s a Taste of What’s on the Way!
By Jen Dixon September 30, 2025
Local Residents Turn Wellness into Connection and Purpose
More Posts